The Biggest Draft Steals in NFL History

The NFL Draft is built around an irresistible idea: teams supposedly get their best chance at future superstars near the top. Reality is considerably messier. Every year, highly regarded prospects disappoint while overlooked players selected hundreds of picks later become franchise legends. Scouts can measure speed, strength and athleticism, but predicting how a college player will handle professional football remains wonderfully imperfect. Some of the greatest players in NFL history spent draft weekend waiting far longer than their careers would eventually suggest.

Tom Brady Turned Pick 199 Into NFL Folklore

No discussion of draft steals can begin anywhere else.

The New England Patriots selected Tom Brady with the 199th overall pick in the sixth round of the 2000 NFL Draft. Six quarterbacks were taken before him.

Brady proceeded to build a résumé that made his draft position almost comical. He won seven Super Bowls, five Super Bowl MVP awards and three regular-season MVP awards while setting numerous major passing records.

What makes the story particularly remarkable is that New England wasn’t necessarily expecting a future franchise quarterback. Brady began his rookie season buried on the depth chart before eventually receiving his opportunity after Drew Bledsoe was injured the following season.

Pick 199 is now shorthand for the ultimate scouting miss.

Joe Montana Lasted Until the Third Round

Before Brady, another legendary quarterback provided an extraordinary example of draft value.

The San Francisco 49ers selected Joe Montana with the 82nd overall pick in the third round of the 1979 draft.

Montana eventually became the centerpiece of one of football’s great dynasties, winning four Super Bowls with San Francisco and earning three Super Bowl MVP awards.

His calm performances in high-pressure moments helped define his career. “Joe Cool” became one of the sport’s most recognizable quarterbacks despite entering the league without anything close to first-round draft status.

Finding a competent starting quarterback in the third round is valuable.

Finding Joe Montana is the kind of result that can reshape an entire franchise.

Shannon Sharpe Was Almost an Afterthought

The Denver Broncos selected Shannon Sharpe in the seventh round with the 192nd overall pick in 1990.

He wasn’t even necessarily viewed as having a clearly defined NFL position.

Sharpe ultimately became one of the players who helped redefine what teams could expect from a receiving tight end. He finished his career with more than 800 receptions, over 10,000 receiving yards and three Super Bowl championships.

He was later inducted into the Pro Football Hall of Fame.

Seventh-round picks often spend training camp fighting simply to make the roster. Sharpe became one of the greatest players ever at his position.

That’s about as much value as a team can squeeze out of a late-round selection.

Terrell Davis Became a Super Bowl MVP

Denver struck late-round gold again just a few years later.

Terrell Davis was selected 196th overall in the sixth round of the 1995 NFL Draft. He initially had to distinguish himself on special teams before earning a larger role.

Once he did, his rise was spectacular.

Davis became the centerpiece of Denver’s rushing attack and produced a 2,008-yard season in 1998. He helped the Broncos win consecutive Super Bowls and was named MVP of Super Bowl XXXII.

Injuries shortened his career, but his peak was extraordinary enough to eventually earn him a place in the Pro Football Hall of Fame.

A sixth-round selection became the offensive engine of a championship team.

Antonio Gates Wasn’t Drafted at All

Sometimes the biggest draft steal technically isn’t a draft pick.

Antonio Gates entered the NFL as an undrafted free agent after playing college basketball at Kent State. His unconventional background meant teams had relatively little traditional football experience to evaluate.

The San Diego Chargers gave him an opportunity.

Gates became one of the defining tight ends of his generation, using basketball-influenced body control and positioning to create matchup problems throughout his career. He finished with 116 receiving touchdowns and was inducted into the Pro Football Hall of Fame in 2025.

Thirty-two teams had multiple opportunities to draft him.

Nobody did.

Jason Kelce Lasted Until Round Six

Interior offensive linemen rarely receive the attention given to quarterbacks and skill-position stars, but landing an elite center late in the draft can transform an offense for years.

The Philadelphia Eagles selected Jason Kelce with the 191st overall pick in the sixth round in 2011.

Kelce eventually became one of the defining players of his era at center, earning seven Pro Bowl selections and six first-team All-Pro honors. He was also a crucial part of Philadelphia’s Super Bowl LII championship team.

His athleticism helped make him particularly effective in space, while his personality turned an offensive lineman into one of the franchise’s most recognizable figures.

Sixth-round picks are supposed to provide depth.

Kelce provided more than a decade of elite play.

Richard Sherman Became the Face of a Legendary Defense

Richard Sherman entered the league as a fifth-round selection after transitioning from wide receiver to cornerback during his college career at Stanford.

The Seattle Seahawks selected him 154th overall in 2011.

He became a foundational member of the “Legion of Boom,” Seattle’s dominant secondary that helped the franchise win Super Bowl XLVIII. Sherman earned multiple first-team All-Pro selections and developed into one of football’s most recognizable defensive stars.

His career is another reminder that draft evaluation involves projection.

Teams aren’t merely judging what a player already is. They’re trying to predict what that player might become after professional coaching and development.

Seattle’s prediction worked spectacularly.

Bart Starr Was Pick 200

The modern draft makes Tom Brady’s selection at 199 seem astonishing. Decades earlier, another championship quarterback went one spot later.

The Green Bay Packers selected Bart Starr with the 200th overall pick in the 17th round of the 1956 NFL Draft.

Starr went on to quarterback Green Bay during the Vince Lombardi era, winning five NFL championships, including the first two Super Bowls. He was named MVP of both Super Bowl I and Super Bowl II and eventually entered the Pro Football Hall of Fame.

Drafts operated very differently during Starr’s era, making direct comparisons with modern selections imperfect.

Even so, the 200th pick becoming the quarterback of one of football’s most celebrated dynasties remains extraordinary.

Why NFL Teams Keep Missing Great Players

It can be tempting to look at these careers and wonder how professional scouts missed something obvious.

The answer is that it usually wasn’t obvious.

College systems differ dramatically from NFL offenses and defenses. Players change positions. Some prospects develop physically after entering the league. Others respond exceptionally well to particular coaches or schemes.

Then there are qualities that are notoriously difficult to measure: decision-making, resilience, preparation and the ability to improve.

The draft is less like selecting finished products and more like predicting hundreds of complicated futures simultaneously.

Teams inevitably get some of them spectacularly wrong.

The Picks That Keep Draft Weekend Interesting

First-round selections will always receive the biggest headlines, but late-round success stories are part of what makes the NFL Draft fascinating.

Every player still available on Saturday represents a possibility.

Most won’t become Hall of Famers. Some won’t make an NFL roster. But history repeatedly demonstrates that franchise-changing talent can remain available long after the television coverage stops treating each selection like a major event.

A future champion might be a third-rounder. An All-Pro could be waiting in the sixth. The next legendary undrafted player might not hear his name called at all.

And somewhere around pick 199, every general manager has another reason to keep paying attention.