Minnesota Vikings
Grade: B+
The Vikings were set on getting receiver help even after they saw three wideouts consecutively selected right before them. Minnesota kept the run on WR’s going with the selection of USC pass catcher Jordan Addison. The team needed another option opposite Justin Jefferson following the departure of longtime stalwart Adam Thielen. Addison plays bigger than his slight frame would suggest, and has impressive route-running chops. Not wanting to stray out of Southern California, the Vikings added another former Trojan in CB Mekhi Blackmon. He’ll help add some youth in a secondary which signed former Cardinal Byron Murphy Jr. this offseason.
After taking two USC players, the Vikings kept with the theme of pairs by taking back-to-back LSU defenders with their next two selections. Jay Ward is a versatile defensive back who can play safety or nickel corner, and DT Jaquelin Roy figures to be a nice rotation piece up front who can help Minnesota’s miserable run defense. Though some predicted the Vikings to use an early pick on a young QB, they waited until Round 5 to address that spot with BYU’s Jaren Hall. He will contend with veteran Nick Mullens for the backup role behind Kirk Cousins.
Image Source: Jaime Valdez-USA TODAY Sports
Green Bay Packers
Grade: B
Much to the chagrin of Green Bay Packer fans, the team spent yet another Day 1 pick on a defender. Lukas Van Ness was selected 13th overall by the Packers with the pick the team received in the Aaron Rodgers trade. Van Ness is a stellar athlete who figures to be an immediate impact player on the edge for Green Bay. While it certainly addressed a position of need, the Packers likely could have traded down once more and still secured Van Ness in the latter-portion of the first round.
Fortunately for young QB Jordan Love, Green Bay spent both of its second-round picks on offensive help. First came TE Luke Musgrave — the first of two tight ends selected by the Packers — out of Oregon State. Then, Michigan State wideout Jayden Reed. Musgrave gives Love a big target who can win on contested catches, while Reed brings a much-needed speed dynamic that will work out of the slot. Tucker Kraft will join Musgrave in the TE room, and is excellent after the catch. With several losses on the defensive front, Colby Wooden out of Auburn could find early playing time despite being a bit undersized for a defensive tackle.
Image Source: Todd Kirkland/Getty Images
Detroit Lions
Grade: C
Detroit certainly had the most puzzling Day 1, trading down to select RB Jahmyr Gibbs with the 12th overall selection. Gibbs’ is a tremendous talent who will see the field early now that D’Andre Swift is with the Eagles. Still, it was a rather aggressive pick — especially after the Lions had the chance to take the consensus No. 1 RB in the draft (Bijan Robinson) with the fifth selection before trading down.
The Lions further spat in the face of “positional value” by taking an off-ball backer with the No. 18 pick. Jack Campbell will be a Day 1 starter in the middle of Detroit’s defense. The Lions took Campbell’s Iowa teammate in Sam LaPorta in Round 2 — to the surprise of many as Notre Dame’s Michael Mayer was still on the board.
Image Source: Gary Cosby Jr.-USA TODAY Sports
Chicago Bears
Grade: A-
The Bears weren’t quite done trading down in the first round. After trading out of the No. 1 overall pick, Chicago traded down once more from No. 9 to No. 10 on draft day. While acquiring an additional fourth-round pick, the Bears eventually used their first selection of the draft on tackle Darnell Wright. It was obvious they needed to get more protection for QB Justin Fields, and they did just that with this pick. Wright will be an immediate starter — likely at right tackle.
Their next three selections all addressed obvious needs across the defense — run-stopping defensive tackle (Gervon Dexter), press corner (Tyrique Stevenson), and another edge rusher (Zacch Pickens). With David Montgomery leaving for Detroit, the Bears were likely to take a RB in this draft. They settled on Texas runner Roschon Johnson who should have fresh legs after backing up Bijan Robinson for the past three years. WR Tyler Scott could be an immediate-impact player who lasted all the way until the end of the fourth round. Blessed with incredible top-end speed, Scott’s ability to stretch the field pairs well with Fields’ vertical style of play.
Image Source: Jamar Coach/News Sentinel / USA TODAY NETWORK
Tampa Bay Buccaneers
Grade: B+
The Buccaneers want to get back to fielding a dominant defense like the one during their Super Bowl run. Calijah Kancey drew comparisons to another undersized defensive tackle out of Pitt — let’s not go there — and was the team’s first-round selection. While he doesn’t figure to be an every-down player right away, Kancey can be a difference-maker if deployed correctly. Looking at the other side of the ball, Tampa Bay got a mauler in North Dakota State’s Cody Mauch. A likely starter at guard, Mauch will help open up holes for Tampa runners.
Edge rusher YaYa Diaby will be used on passing downs as a pass rusher, and off-ball backer SirVocea Dennis could find early-down work for his ability to play run support. The offense added two new weapons in 6-foot-6 TE Payne Durham and speedy wideout (4.33 40-yard dash) Trey Palmer.
Image Source: Joe Sargent/Getty Images
New Orleans Saints
Grade: B
The Saints had an obvious need of getting younger and more athletic on the defensive line. With Marcus Davenport leaving and Payton Turner not flashing much as a rookie, the Saints were essentially forced into revamping that group. That led to them possibly reaching with each of their first two picks. Clemson’s Bryan Bresee will be a great run defender, but his ability to rush the passer was inconsistent for the Tigers. Isaiah Foskey is more adept at rushing the passer, but went about 40 picks ahead of expectation.
In the third, the Saints addressed a rather large elephant in the room with the selection of TCU RB Kendre Miller — putting the future of former All-Pro Alvin Kamara in doubt. With the Miller pick and the offseason signing of Jamaal Williams, the Saints could be preparing for a lengthy suspension for their star back. Old Dominion tackle Nick Saldiveri will be an important depth piece at tackle. The Saints also added a second Fresno State hurler to their QB room with the selection of Jake Haener. He will be joining former Bulldog and mentor Derek Carr.
Image Source: Ken Ruinard-USA TODAY Sports
Atlanta Falcons
Grade: B+
After taking offensive skill players in the first round of each of the past two drafts (Kyle Pitts and Drake London), the Falcons continued that trend by taking do-it-all back Bijan Robinson. The Texas standout was considered a top-3 prospect — regardless of position — in the entire class. He’ll be used in all sorts of ways in Arthur Smith’s offense, and gives young signal caller Desmond Ridder yet another weapon to utilize.
Previous Falcons teams that boasted considerable talent have been thwarted by shaky offensive lines. In an effort to remedy that, Atlanta’s used its second pick on Syracuse lineman Matthew Bergeron. He has experience playing guard and both tackle spots, and that kind of versatility will be extremely helpful for a Falcons line still trying to find its footing. Zach Harrison was a highly-touted recruit that could find early playing time due to Atlanta’s lack of consistent pass rushers. A ballhawk at Utah, CB Clark Phillips lack of size won’t be quite as apparent in Atlanta’s zone-heavy scheme.
Image Source: Kirby Lee-USA TODAY Sports
Carolina Panthers
Grade: B
Bryce Young highlights a Panthers draft that was predictably thin following its trade for the top pick. Of course, if Young is everything scouts and fans believe him to be then the rest of the class won’t matter quite as much. Still, getting quality players in the margins is paramount for a team like the Panthers (which already boasts a rather talented roster). In the second round, Carolina grabbed Ole Miss wideout Jonathan Mingo (who had been rapidly rising up boards prior to the draft). The QB-WR pairing will now have the chance to build chemistry from the onset.
Oregon’s DJ Johnson was one of just two picks spent on defenders. The edge rusher has an intriguing combination of speed and size which could earn him work in obvious passing situations. Chandler Zavala — one of the draft’s top interior offensive lineman — and versatile Florida State DB Jammie Robinson concluded a rather successful draft for the Panthers.
Image Source: Gary Cosby Jr.-USA TODAY Sports
Tennessee Titans
Grade: B+
Can’t go wrong with getting OT Peter Skoronski off the board at pick No. 11. He was one of the draft’s premier tackles and will be a stalwart for a rebuilding Tennessee offensive line. After they probably considered him in the first-round, Kentucky hurler Will Levis surprisingly fell into Day 2. The Titans traded up to the second pick of the second round to take Levis, who will supposedly start out as QB3 behind longtime starter Ryan Tannehill and 2022 draftee Malik Willis.
Tulane back Tyjae Spears could be a great addition to this offense. Electric in the open field, Spears will be used as both a runner and receiver at the next level. We also particularly liked the value Tennessee got on Maryland OT Jaelyn Duncan — an excellent run blocker who started all four years at Maryland.
Image Source: USA TODAY Sports
Jacksonville Jaguars
Grade: C
It was a bit of a mixed bag for the Jaguars, who made 13 picks over three days. Their lone Day 1 pick was used on Oklahoma tackle Anton Harrison who projects to slot in at right tackle to begin the season. The fifth offensive lineman taken off the board, Harrison had more of a second-round grade entering the draft. Though, the Jaguars had an obvious need at the position with presumed starter Cam Robinson facing a multi-game suspension to start the year.
The Jaguars draft got even weirder from there. Jacksonville doubled up on TE with Penn State’s Brenton Strange after getting a strong season out of Evan Engram last year. We understand 2-TE sets are all the rage in 2023, but that doesn’t seem like a great use of resources. Especially when it was followed up with yet another running back in Round 3 with Auburn’s Tank Bigsby. The former Tiger figures to be the thunder to Travis Etienne’s lightning. Jacksonville spent their next four picks on defenders, with the most intriguing selection being DB Antonio Johnson — a rangy 6-foot-2 defender who could thrive as a nickel corner.
Image Source: Brian Bahr/Getty Images
Indianapolis Colts
Grade: A
The Colts swung for the fences, and we have to give them credit for doing so. Anthony Richardson has the highest ceiling of any QB in the class, but his development will be key as he looks to improve in several areas. We love his chances of succeeding in Indianapolis, especially when we analyze the rest of their draft.
In the second-round, Indy continued to build up their defensive backfield with K-State’s Julius Brents. The 6-foot-3 corner could prove to be extremely valuable as a shadow for bigger wideouts. Adding Josh Downs to the WR room is exactly what that group was missing. He’s the ideal speedy, slot wideout next to Alec Pierce and Michael Pittman Jr. Northwestern DE Adetomiwa Adebawore is an absolute freak of an athlete who ran a 4.49 40-yard dash at 280 pounds. The Colts somehow got him in Round 4.
Image Source: Kirby Lee-USA TODAY Sports
Houston Texans
Grade: A-
Houston wasted no time making the first big move of the draft. After selecting Ohio State gunslinger C.J. Stroud with the second overall pick, the Texans shocked everyone when they reappeared on the clock moments later. Houston traded four picks to move up to No. 3 (plus adding No. 105) to select the top defender on the board in Will Anderson. We spoke about this in the first-round grades piece, but the Texans obviously did a marvelous job here selecting two potential cornerstones on either side of the ball.
That being said, nailing the second and third overall picks in the draft isn’t exactly rocket science. While Houston should be applauded for their aggressiveness to move up, what they’re able to do with the rest of their draft capital could ultimately decided the next several years. Houston added some much needed depth to their interior line with the selection of two natural centers — Juice Scruggs and Jarrett Patterson. With an obvious need at pass catcher, the Texans took nearby wideout Nathaniel Dell in the third round. The former Houston Cougar is one of the most polished route runners in the entire class.
Image Source: Todd Kirkland/Getty Images
Pittsburgh Steelers
Grade: A+
From a positional-need and value perspective, the Steelers arguably had the best draft of any team. In the middle of the first-round, Pittsburgh nabbed the last potential franchise tackle in Georgia’s Broderick Jones. The Steelers did have to trade up to secure their guy, but it’s a small price for a player who further enhances the development of the team’s two previous first-round picks (QB Kenny Pickett and RB Najee Harris).
In the second, Pittsburgh called upon a familiar name to bolster their secondary. Joey Porter Jr. plays just like his former Steeler father — except he’s a 6-foot-2, 200-pound, press corner instead of a 250-pound edge rusher. He figures to get playing time early due Pittsburgh’s thinness at the position. Wisconsin’s Keeanu Benton fits the mold of a 3-4 defensive tackle that provides consistent push upfront. Though they already have Pat Freiermuth, the Steelers couldn’t pass on TE Darnell Washington in the fourth round. Washington creates matchup problems at 6-foot-7, and is basically a sixth blocker on the edge of the line.
Image Source: Jay Biggerstaff/Getty Images
Cleveland Browns
Grade: C
Cleveland had to wait all the way until the third round to make their first selection. That’s the price a team pays for giving away half of their draft for a “franchise” QB. In their effort to build the offense around Deshaun Watson, the Browns’ first selection (No. 74 overall) was used on Tennessee WR Cedric Tillman. Standing at 6-foot-3 with a large catch radius, Tillman will give this offense another big target opposite 6-foot-2 Donovan Peoples-Jones.
The Browns added depth to both lines with four of their final six picks. Siaki Ika is an enormous defensive tackle that could be a factor in the run game early. In the fourth round, OT Dawand Jones presented tremendous value as insurance for starters Jack Conklin and Jedrick Willis Jr. Day 3 saw Cleveland make a play for a development QB in UCLA’s Dorian Thompson-Robinson. The former Bruin will likely start as QB3 behind Watson and backup Joshua Dobbs, but boasts intriguing athletic tools which could earn him playing time in a different role.
Image Source: Saul Young/USA TODAY Sports
Cincinnati Bengals
Grade: B
The Bengals fought the urge of adding to their already explosive offense in Round 1, opting for edge rusher Myles Murphy instead of TE Michael Mayer. There’s no doubt Cincinnati could use a boost up front defensively. Despite boasting one of the league’s better defenses last season, Cincy finished 29th in sacks and were routinely coming up short of bringing down opposing quarterbacks. Murphy is a perfect fit with the Bengals — as his size and athleticism give him the potential to deployed at multiple spots.
Second-round selection DJ Turner could help define this class for Cincinnati. What Turner lacks in size he makes up for in speed and instincts. The 5-foot-11 corner ran a 4.26 40-yard dash at the combine and was well-coached at Michigan. He’ll already be familiar with one of his new teammates, safety Daxton Hill, from their time as Wolverines together.
Image Source: Winslow Townson-USA TODAY Sports
Baltimore Ravens
Grade: A
It’s difficult to not get excited about what the Ravens have over the last couple of weeks — highlighted by re-upping franchise QB Lamar Jackson to a massive extension. The Ravens already showed their commitment to getting Jackson more weapons with the addition of wide receiver Odell Beckham Jr. — but the team didn’t stop there. With their first-round pick, Baltimore added another wideout in Boston College’s Zay Flowers. A quick-twitch route runner, Flowers is adept at generating separation between himself and defenders.
The Ravens added some athleticism on the defensive side of the ball with their next three picks, adding to all three levels with linebacker Trenton Simpson, edge rusher Tavius Robinson, and corner Kyu Blu Kelly. Simpson is the most intriguing of the bunch, as his range and coverage skills could potentially make former first-rounder Patrick Queen expendable. In the seventh, the Ravens arguably got the steal of the draft in USC’s Andrew Vorhees. The burly guard is set to miss the entire season after tearing his ACL at the combine, but could be an excellent long-term stash.
Image Source: Winslow Townson-USA TODAY Sports
Los Angeles Rams
Grade: B+
Currently in a bit of a rebuilding process, the Rams were loaded with picks — making a whopping 14 selections between Day 2 and Day 3. The obvious hope is that the franchise will ‘hit’ on some of these guys. At the very least, it’s feasible to assume that second-round pick Steve Avila out of TCU will start up front along the offensive line. He’s a mauler in the run game, and very good in pass protection.
Third-round pick Byron Young was quite active during his time at Tennessee. He could provide the Rams with some pass-rushing production off the edge. We really like DT Kobie Turner out of Wake Forest (he could play sooner than you’d think). If you’re looking for a late round sleeper, Sixth-round pick DB Tre’Vius Hodges-Tomlinson was a stud at TCU. He could walk into the Rams’ secondary and offer some help at nickel. All in all, this was a very solid draft in terms of helping to rebuild the team’s depth.
Image Source: Tom Hauck/Getty Images
Los Angeles Chargers
Grade: B
With Zay Flowers on the board, the Chargers opted to instead take Quentin Johnston mid-way through the first round. There’s no denying his speed or size on the perimeter. Still, with Keenan Allen and Mike Williams already on the roster, you wonder whether the Chargers could’ve selected a receiver with a bit of a different profile.
With that said, we like the next three picks by the Chargers’ front office. USC’s Tuli Tuipulotu was arguably the best defensive lineman in the Pac-12 this year. He has the versatility to play all along the defensive line. Daiyan Henley out of Washington State is a highly active linebacker with some plus-athleticism. Lastly, LA rolled the dice on another TCU receiver — this time being Derius Davis. Davis is a sub-4.4 guy with real value in the return game.
Image Source: Tim Heitman-USA TODAY Sports
San Francisco 49ers
Grade: C
San Francisco didn’t pick until the third round. We didn’t love what they did — spending a third on a kicker (Jake Moody) and another on a TE (Cameron Latu) who figured to still be around potentially in the fifth round. Moody will take over for longtime kicker Robbie Gould now that he’s departing.
The secondary needed a reboot — which should come via Penn State safety Ji’Ayir Brown (a player the team is said to be very high on). From there, fifth-round pick Robert Beal out of Georgia could provide the 49ers with situational pass rushing.
Image Source: Kirby Lee/USA TODAY Sports
Kansas City Chiefs
Grade: B+
When you’re a good franchise, it should come as little surprise to see said team drafting well year after year. Yet again, the Chiefs were able to add players from the prep ranks that should come in right away and help.
Chief among them, local prospect Felix Anundike-Uzomah. Hailing from K-State, Anundike-Uzomah graded out as a terror on the edge. He constantly pressured opposing quarterbacks, and a deep dive into the analytic breakdown indicates he was one of the most successful pass rushing threats within the Big-12. He should immediately make an impact for KC.
Additionally, Rashee Rice gives the Chiefs a deep threat within its WR corps. OT Wanya Morris out of Oklahoma is talented enough to potentially be a developmental starter down the line. Other than that, Texas nose guard Keondre Coburn could see some time as a run-stuffing option.
Image Source: Scott Winters/Getty Images
Las Vegas Raiders
Grade: B
We don’t love the Raiders’ first-round pick. While Tyree Wilson is a fantastic athlete, corner was a more pressing need. However, the team bounced back terrifically in the second round to nab Michael Mayer out of Notre Dame. The big TE will immediately be a starter for the franchise, and he could very well prove to be one of the bigger steals in this draft.
The mid-round selections of Jakorian Bennett and Tre Tucker were clearly aimed at improving the team’s athleticism — particularly on special teams. Fifth-round selection Christopher Smith (from Georgia) looks like a guy who could end up not only making the team — but potentially getting some snaps as a rookie.
Image Source: John E. Moore/Getty Images
Seattle Seahawks
Grade: A+
Most people had Seattle rolling the dice on Jalen Carter here. Others thought they’d maybe stash a QB behind Geno Smith. Instead — in pure Pete Carroll fashion — Seattle opted for presumably the best corner in the draft in Devon Witherspoon. He graded out phenomenally well last year at Illinois, and it wouldn’t be a shock to see him become a Pro Bowler as soon as next year.
Witherspoon was followed by a plethora of really smart picks. Jaxon Smith-Njigba is a supremely gifted receiver, adding yet another weapon to the offense. Zach Charbonnet was one of the country’s best running backs last year, offering a combination of quick feet, pass-catching ability, vision, and the penchant for breaking tackles. Auburn’s Derick Hall could be a difference-maker immediately off the edge, LSU’s Anthony Bradford could become a starter as an interior offensive lineman, and fourth-round nab Cameron Young out of Mississippi State may end up among the best picks of this crop. Heck — even the Michigan duo of Mike Morris and Olusegun Oluwatimi could end up very good pros one day.
In short, this was a home run draft for the Seahawks.
Image Source: Matt Krohn-USA TODAY Sports
Arizona Cardinals
Grade: A
More than anything, the Cardinals needed some stability moving forward. This draft seemed to signal a move in the right direction. Moving down to accrue more draft capital, Arizona nabbed the top OT in the draft in Paris Johnson (a move to surely help Kyler Murray). From there, LSU’s BJ Ojulari — a guy often lauded for his work ethic and energy — was taken in the second round. Both picks look to be very good value-wise.
The secondary got better with the addition of Syracuse’s Garrett Williams. Stanford’s Michael Wilson is more of a possession receiver with terrific ball skills. Keep an eye out for UCLA’s Jon Gaines. Grading out as one of the most explosive guards in the draft, he played every position along the offensive line for the Bruins. Additionally, he’s super smart and a future team leader.
Image Source: Michael Reaves/Getty Images
Denver Broncos
Grade: C+
In the wake of the Russell Wilson trade, the Broncos didn’t have a ton to do throughout the weekend. Denver had only five picks in total. In Round 2, wanting to get Wilson some help, the Broncos took Oklahoma deep threat Marvin Mims. He’s a guy who should help stretch the field vertically.
Drew Sanders is a very good athlete — having played both inside and on the edge for Arkansas. At the very worst, Sanders and fellow third-round pick Riley Moss (out of Iowa) will be special teams guys. Moss actually has the profile of a guy who outplays his draft spot. He’s experienced, intelligent, and has good ball skills.
Image Source: Nelson Chenault-USA TODAY Sports
New York Jets
Grade: B
After improving its offensive skill talent considerably in the offseason, the Jets opted to nab DE Will McDonald out of Iowa State midway through the first round. While McDonald is a decent player, this pick appears to be a bit of a reach. He probably could’ve been had at the end of the first round/early second round. There’s also not much of a track record when it comes to McDonald stringing together multiple good seasons in Ames.
With that said, the offensive line was addressed in rounds 2/3 with center Joe Tippmann and tackle Carter Warren, respectively. Tippmann comes from the offensive lineman factory that is Wisconsin, and Warren should be able to function as a reserve early. Other than that, we really liked the gabbing of Pitt RB Israel Abanikanda in the fifth round. As they say, he’s got ‘some juice’ when it comes to accelerating in space.
Image Source: Zach Boyden-Holmes/The Register / USA TODAY NETWORK
New York Giants
Grade: A
The Giants did well in filling some areas of concern with this draft. First-round pick Deonte Banks is one of the fastest and most gifted athletes in this entire draft. Getting a guy with this sort of upside late in the first round is rather rare. He’s truly got all-pro potential should he develop well.
Second-round pick John Michael Schmitz was one of the better interior linemen in the Big Ten. A four-year starter at Minnesota, he’s got the ‘look’ of a 10-year starter in the NFL — utilizing brute strength with nimbleness and brains. Tennessee WR Jalin Hyatt dropped all the way to the third round despite dominating the SEC this past year. While a bit thin, there’s no denying his big-play ability.
Image Source: Jeff Hanisch-USA TODAY Sports
Washington Football Team
Grade: B
This might not be a draft chock-full of high-end difference makers for Washington. However, we do think it can offer some very solid depth pieces at multiple spots.
Emmanuel Forbes is a terrific athlete from Mississippi State. He’s a true ballhawk from the corner spot — and should start right away. In the second round, Washington went back to the secondary well and nabbed Illinois corner Jartavius Martin (a guy who’s played both corner and safety in his collegiate career).
From there, the offensive line was beefed up. Center Ricky Stromberg (Arkansas) and tackle Braeden Daniels (Utah) were taken in consecutive rounds. Both have a chance to stick as rotation guys this year. Lastly, we like the Round 6 selection of Chris Rodriguez. When healthy, the Kentucky back flashed some above-average ability in accruing YAC.
Image Source: Justin Forbes/Getty Images
Miami Dolphins
Grade: C+
It was a very quiet draft for the Dolphins. Miami had only four picks over the three days (Two of which were taken in the sixth and seventh rounds). There’s not a whole lot to take away — though we’ll focus on second-round pick DB Cam Smith and third-round pick RB Devon Achane.
Smith comes from South Carolina — where he was tested weekly versus top competition in the SEC. He’s a bit of a ball magnet, and has the versatility to play both on the perimeter and in the slot as a nickel corner.
Achane is a true home run hitter. Blessed with electric speed (4.32 in the 40-yard dash), he’s the type of guy you get out in space at all costs. We actually think he can be a factor in this offense similarly to how the 49ers used Raheem Mostert a few years ago.
Image Source: Maria Lysaker/USA TODAY Sports
New England Patriots
Grade: A-
In true New England fashion, the Patriots loaded up on picks (12 of them to be exact).
The front office must’ve been doing cartwheels when Christian Gonzalez dropped to them at No. 17. A big, physical corner out of Oregon, he’ll immediately start from Day 1. The same probably will be said for Georgia Tech DE Keion White (who appears to be a perfect fit in a 3-4 alignment).
The mid-round picks were arguably the most intriguing. In Rounds 4 and 5, the Pats picked up two maulers in the interior of the offensive line. Eastern Washington OG Sidy Sow is known for his athleticism. UCLA guard Atonio Mafi — a former nose guard — has massive hands, terrific feet, and ridiculous strength. When paired with fellow fourth-round selection in center Jake Andrews, the Pats may have just rebuilt 3/5ths of its starting OL group in one draft.
And of course…we can’t forget to mention Round 6 selection Kayshon Boutte out of LSU. For whatever reason, he went from being a surefire 1st rounder preseason to dropping all the way to the 6th after a rough 2022-23 year in Baton Rouge. On talent alone, he makes a case as being the most gifted receiver in this class.
Image Source: Mark J. Rebilas/USA TODAY Sports
Buffalo Bills
Grade: B+
Why not keep Josh Allen happy? While the defense does need some help, the Bills went offense with their first two picks. Dalton Kincaid was nabbed towards the end of the first round. At Utah, he was virtually unstoppable from the slot. Kincaid not only has terrific hands, but he’s super competitive and isn’t shy when making the tough catch in traffic. He’ll immediately become a fan favorite.
O’Cyrus Torrence is a big guard from Florida. Some projections had him going in the first round. However, he fell to the middle of the second round where he projects to be a starter early in his career. In Round 3, the Bills traded up to get speedy ‘backer Dorian Williams. Hailing from Tulane, he’s known primarily for his coverage skills and closing speed.
Image Source: Chris Pietsch / USA TODAY NETWORK
Philadelphia Eagles
Grade: A
The Georgia-to-Philadelphia pipeline is still going strong. The Eagles took two Bulldogs in the first round this year. Jalen Carter might be the most talented player in this draft, and the Eagles were able to trade up and get him at No. 9. Not only does he fill a huge need up front, but he’s an elite talent when not distracted by off-the-field issues. Nolan Smith is a sub-4.4 linebacker with terrific instincts and even better character. For an aging group of pass rushers and outside linebackers, getting Smith was a major plus.
We also liked the additions of Alabama tackle Tyler Steen, physical Illinois safety Sydney Brown, and Georgia corner Kelee Ringo (who unexpectedly fell to Round 4). Even Tanner McKee — the gunslinger from Stanford — has some terrific value as a 6th Round guy who can pump the ball downfield with real velocity.
Image Source: Steve Limentani/ISI Photos/Getty Images
Dallas Cowboys
Grade: B-
The Cowboys had the chance to either trade up for Kincaid, or draft Mayer. Instead, they went defensive tackle with Michigan product Mazi Smith. To be fair, he’s not a bad player by any stretch. We’ll see how much of a difference maker he can be from Day 1.
In the second round, Dallas went back to the University of Michigan — this time for a TE in Luke Schoonmaker. Most projections had him going in the third round. We don’t necessarily see a dynamic pass-catching threat (though surely coming from Jim Harbaugh’s world — he’ll be well-coached and disciplined). Linebacker DeMarvion Overshown from Texas was a solid get in the third round. We also love the addition of diminutive yet explosive RB Deuce Vaughn in the 6th. His dad works for the Cowboys in the personnel department, and the younger Vaughn himself terrorized Big 12 defenses with suddenness and cat-quick agility.
Image Source: Sean Gardner/Getty Images
Draft Grades For 1st Round of 2023-24 NFL Draft
1. Carolina Panthers: QB Bryce Young
Grade: A
Leading up to the draft, it became clear the Panthers had keyed in on Bryce Young as the top pick. Carolina has been missing a difference-making signal caller since Cam Newton’s MVP season in 2015. Young will be joining a roster that doesn’t necessarily reflect a team selecting first overall. The Panthers are talented despite trading away both Christian McCaffrey and D.J. Moore in the last six months. Picking a QB was a no-brainer for the Panthers once they traded up to No. 1, and Young was the top-ranked passer on the board.
Image Source: Sean Gardner/Getty Images
2. Houston Texans: QB C.J. Stroud
Grade: A
There were rumblings Houston was considering a defensive player in this spot instead of a quarterback. Instead, the Texans threw an early curveball in the draft by taking the second QB off the board. C.J. Stroud is the most accurate thrower in the draft, and is coming off two monstrous seasons at Ohio State. He projects to be a Day 1 starter — and is an obvious upgrade over Davis Mills. Passing on a QB with this selection would have been potentially disastrous for the Texans. They did not make that mistake.
Image Source: Todd Kirkland/Getty Images
3. Houston Texans: DE Will Anderson
Grade: B+
Coming away with a potential franchise QB plus arguably the best defensive player in the draft is a sound strategy. After taking C.J Stroud second overall, the Texans quickly found themselves back on the clock. Houston gave up a total of four picks to snag the No. 3 pick (plus No. 105). With it, the Texans selected a future cornerstone defender for new head coach DeMeco Ryans. Will Anderson is a blue-chip edge rusher who could potentially transform the Texans defense. While we’re a bit weary of the draft capital Houston sent out (included a 2024 first-rounder), we can’t fault their strategy given Anderson’s elite talent level.
Image Source: Brandon Sumrall/Getty Images
4. Indianapolis Colts: QB Anthony Richardson
Grade: A
Yet another swerve. The Colts had been heavily linked to QB Will Levis all week leading up to the draft. With Levis still on the board at No. 4, it seemed likely that’s the direction Indianapolis was headed. Instead, another signal-caller got the call from Indy as the team selected Florida’s Anthony Richardson. Richardson is seen by some as a project who will need time to develop. However, the uber-athletic QB has elite physical tools, and could be a game-changer for a Colts team in a winnable AFC South.
Image Source: USA TODAY Sports
5. Seattle Seahawks: CB Devon Witherspoon
Grade: A
Seattle chose to address the secondary instead of the defensive front with the selection of the top CB on the board in Illinois’ Devon Witherspoon. What Witherspoon lacks in size he makes up for in physicality and instincts. A natural playmaker, Witherspoon has quality coverage skills and is elite in run support. He’s the perfect fit in Pete Carroll’s defense which asks so much out of its defensive backs. Witherspoon will form a dynamic duo alongside Pro Bowler Tariq Woolen.
Image Source: Michael Allio/Icon Sportswire/Getty Images
6. Arizona Cardinals: OT Paris Johnson Jr.
Grade: B+
Arizona shuffled around a bit before landing versatile offensive lineman Paris Johnson Jr. at sixth overall. The Cardinals traded down from No. 3 to No. 12 after a deal with the Texans. With Detroit on the clock, Arizona jumped on the opportunity to move up in the draft (likely because they caught wind another team was eyeing Johnson Jr.). With Kyler Murray being banged up in each of the past two seasons, the Cardinals knew they needed to acquire their franchise QB some more protection up front. Johnson Jr. likely slides into a tackle role, but also has experience playing guard.
Image Source: Joe Robbins/Getty Images
7. Las Vegas Raiders: DE Tyree Wilson
Grade: A
There’s a few ways to look at Vegas’ selection of Tyree Wilson. For one, Wilson was projected to go as high as No. 2 to the Texans. And, make no mistake about it, Wilson is an explosive, 6-foot-6 edge rusher who could end up being the best defender of the draft. There’s an argument to be made that edge rusher wasn’t Vegas’ most pressing need. The Raiders’ defensive backfield needs a ton of help, especially at corner. Still, they’ll have an early pick in the second round to potentially fill that spot while adding a strong pass rusher to a group which already includes Maxx Crosby and Chandler Jones.
Image Source: John E. Moore/Getty Images
8. Atlanta Falcons: RB Bijan Robinson
Grade: C
Bijan Robinson was considered one of the top prospects — regardless of position — in the entire draft. The Texas running back was dynamic for the Longhorns, exhibiting excellent burst, strength, agility and a knack for breaking off big runs. Atlanta will utilize Robinson optimally as both a runner and receiver in Arthur Smith’s offense. However, this wasn’t the best selection from a positional value standpoint. Though running backs are coming back into style, the Falcons boast one of the league’s most decrepit defenses and have now spend three consecutive first-round picks on offensive skill players (Robinson, Drake London and Kyle Pitts). They’re going to have to score a ton of points next year to make this pick worth it.
Image Source: Tim Warner/Getty Images
9. Philadelphia Eagles: DL Jalen Carter
Grade: A+
Following a Super Bowl appearance last season, the Eagles went into the draft in an uniquely powerful position. After watching how the picks were shaping up, Philly’s front office was waiting for the best opportunity to strike. In the end, they had to move up just one spot (at the cost of a fourth-round pick) to select arguably the most talented single player in the entire draft. Jalen Carter was a game-wrecker for Georgia, and now joins an Eagles defense which led the league in sacks last season. Good luck to the rest of the NFC East teams that have to block Philadelphia’s defensive front.
Image Source: Jonathan Bachman/Getty Images
10. Chicago Bears: OT Darnell Wright
Grade: B
The Bears keep compiling picks after trading down for a second time this year. Chicago — who originally held the No. 1 selection this year — moved down one spot from No. 9 to No. 10 on draft day. In addition to adding another mid-round pick, the Bears selected a future starting tackle in Tennessee’s Darnell Wright. Chicago’s offensive line was dreadful last year, and protecting Justin Fields is of the utmost importance for this franchise. Though, we aren’t quite sure if the Bears took the best offensive tackle who was available on the board…
Image Source: Megan Briggs/Getty Images
11. Tennessee Titans: OT Peter Skoronski
Grade: B+
There were talks of the Titans moving up and taking one of the quarterbacks. They stood pat and selected Northwestern OL Peter Skoronski instead. The Titans needed to remake their offensive line after parting with Taylor Lewan, Nate Davis and Ben Jones this offseason. Skoronski is a great value here because he can slot in at either tackle or guard spot. It’s not a sexy pick, but the Titans had an obvious need up front and addressed it immediately. There’s no shame in making a boring selection.
Image Source: Michael Reaves/Getty Images
12. Detroit Lions: RB Jahmyr Gibbs
Grade: D
In one of the biggest Day 1 surprises, the Lions traded down from No. 6 to No. 12 (not all that shocking) only to select another RB in Alabama’s Jahmyr Gibbs (completely shocking). It was made obvious that the Lions had no interest in the available prospects at No. 6 once Devon Witherspoon was taken off the board. However, if they wanted a running back — why didn’t they just select Bijan Robinson at No. 6? Gibbs is a fine player — and could prove to be valuable as a receiver — but this was a puzzling pick from a team that already employs D’Andre Swift and David Montgomery (the latter of which was given $11 million guaranteed this offseason).
Image Source: Chris McDill/Getty Images
13. Green Bay Packers: DL Lukas Van Ness
Grade: D+
It would have been fitting if the Packers used this pick to finally draft a first-round WR following Aaron Rodgers’ departure. Alas, the Packers once again added to their defense in the form of Iowa edge rusher Lukas Van Ness. It wasn’t necessarily a home run selection. Van Ness has intriguing physical tools and prototypical size, but feels like a bit of a reach at this spot. And, the Packers still haven’t seriously addressed their porous WR room. With every single pass catcher still on the board to this point, it really feels like the Packers missed an opportunity to get new QB Jordan Love a top target here.
Image Source: Keith Gillett/Getty Images
14. Pittsburgh Steelers: OT Broderick Jones
Grade: B
Sensing a potential for a team to snag their pick, the Steelers moved up three spots to No. 17 to select Georgia lineman Broderick Jones. A strong tackle with quick feet, Jones has a chance to become a cornerstone along Pittsburgh’s line. This pick makes a ton of sense for many reasons. Of course, the Steelers have a young QB they need to protect in Kenny Pickett. Plus, Pittsburgh doesn’t have many glaring holes outside of its offensive line. One player who should be especially pleased with this pick is Steelers RB Najee Harris. Jones excels as a run blocker, and should help spring Harris for big plays on the ground.
Image Source: Jay Biggerstaff/Getty Images
15. New York Jets: DE Will McDonald
Grade: C
Iowa State edge rusher Will McDonald was quietly rising up boards leading up to the draft. We wouldn’t consider this as much of a reach as other outlets, but we would have preferred the Jets go in a different direction here. Especially when you consider the lack of depth in their secondary. New York could have followed in Seattle’s footsteps by grabbing another outside corner to pair with their rookie sensation. With two elite CB’s still on the board, the Jets missed the chance to get Sauce Gardner a partner on the opposite side.
Image Source: Getty Images
16. Washington Commanders: CB Emmanuel Forbes
Grade: B
We like this pick for Washington. The only real knock on Forbes is his slender frame. He might weigh 170 pounds (and only if soaking wet). However, you’d expect him to physically get bigger as he ages. Stylistically, you’re looking at a guy who excels in coverage. Forbes is a total ball hawk — evidenced by nabbing 14 picks over the last three years. His sub-4.4 speed shows up in film quite clearly, and he can function well in different coverage package. Plus — Forbes was tested weekly in the SEC. He looks like a true No. 1 corner in this league.
Image Source: Justin Ford/Getty Images
17. New England Patriots: CB Christian Gonzalez
Grade: A
This is one of the biggest steals in the first round. Bill Belichick had success taking one Oregon DB years ago (Patrick Chung). The hopes are that lighting can strike twice here. Gonzalez is a big corner — standing a legit 6-foot-1. You’re looking at a guy who’s both physical in run support but also smooth in coverage when flipping his hips and changing directions. Rarely do you see such a fluid athlete at Gonzalez’s size. We love this fit — and think he’ll impact with his versatility right away.
Image Source: Tom Hauck/Getty Images
18. Detroit Lions: LB Jack Campbell
Grade: D
Aside from sharing the same surname, we understand why the Lions’ head coach would like this player. Jack Campbell is a throwback middle ‘backer — standing at 6-foot-5 and weighing close to 250 pounds. Coming from Iowa, you know he will be physical and technically sound. Where you do worry is when Campbell could get isolated in space. He’s not the quickest player — and there are questions whether he can be an every-down player. Plus, most draft evals had him going late in the second round. Seems as if the Lions reached big-time here. It’s also a bit of a strange pick given Detroit signed Alex Anzalone to a multi-year deal. But…we’ll see what happens.
Image Source: Keith Gillett/Getty Images
19. Tampa Bay Buccaneers: DL Calijah Kancey
Grade: B
The Bucs need to get younger and more talented across the board. This could be a situation where the staff felt as if Kancey was the best remaining player on the board. He should immediately be a starter from Day 1. While not the biggest defensive tackle in the world, Kancey’s bread-and-butter is using both leverage and quickness to collapse the heart of the pocket en route to signal-callers. We’re talking about a guy with elite first-step quickness for the position. While he’s not Aaron Donald, there are some similarities beyond just attending the same university.
Image Source: Joe Sargent/Getty Images
20. Seattle Seahawks: WR Jaxon Smith-Njigba
Grade: A+
What a grab by the Seahawks. Many feel as if JSN is the best receiver in this entire draft. We saw the talent pop off the screen at Ohio State — where Smith-Njigba was seemingly open on every single play. This isn’t by accident, as his ability to create space for himself via route running and tracking the ball is simply superb. Smith-Njigba gives the Seahawks yet another weapon to go against the 49ers. In the process, the new WR trio of DK Metcalf-Tyler Lockett-Jaxon Smith-Njigba is among the most talented in all of professional football.
Image Source: Harry How/Getty Images
21. Los Angeles Chargers: WR Quentin Johnston
Grade: B-
While the Chargers did take a receiver, it’s not the one we expected. LA already has a plethora of big, strong receivers within its core (Josh Palmer, Keenan Allen, Mike Williams). Adding a quick, fast, slot guy would’ve made a ton of sense for Justin Herbert. The type of guy that could be an outlet with the ability to make plays in space. That guy — Zay Flowers — was still on the board when the Chargers took Johnston out of TCU. To be fair, he’s a freak athlete with some real upside at 6-foot-3. We just wonder if he’s a bit redundant with Williams already in tow. Or — the Chargers figure that boasting a fleet of jumbo receivers could make life very difficult for the opposition.
Image Source: Jordan Kelly/Getty Images
22. Baltimore Ravens: WR Zay Flowers
Grade: A
We love this pick for Baltimore. After ponying up the cash (rightfully so) to keep Lamar Jackson, the team opted to smartly get him some help. To say the production from Baltimore’s receivers was anemic last year would be an understatement. This unit desperately needed some juice in the offseason. By adding OBJ and Flowers, respectively, Jackson now has some skill to work with. Flowers is ridiculously agile in the open field — and should immediately become a favored target of Jackson, especially on drags and screens.
Image Source: Getty Images
23. Minnesota Vikings: WR Jordan Addison
Grade: B
With Adam Thielen now in Carolina, it would make sense for the Vikings to add some talent to its WR room opposite Justin Jefferson. On paper, Addison makes a ton of sense. He’s a big-play receiver with terrific 50/50 ball skills. Duly, Addison is also known for his crisp route-running. There’s a world in which he could become the next Amon-Ra St. Brown — especially because he wasn’t fully healthy last year. Had he been, Addison could’ve been selected much higher. In short, Minnesota may have got some great value here.
Image Source: Keith Birmingham/Getty Images
24. New York Giants: CB Deonte Banks
Grade: B+
Another solid pick here for the G-Men. Banks is a semi-local player from the Northeast region of the country. He has the modern-day blend in being 6-feet tall and nearly 200 pounds — yet still running a sub-4.4 40. Pressing receivers at the line of scrimmage seems to be Banks’s calling card. You’d expect him to come in and start right away. At the very worse, he increases the respective athleticism within the team.
Image Source: Mark Goldman/Icon Sportswire/Getty Images
25. Buffalo Bills: TE Dalton Kincaid
Grade: A
This is a perfect marriage. Bills Mafia will love this kid — who was a total underdog his entire career before exploding onto the scene when he got his shot at Utah. Kincaid has exceptionally good hands — making the tough catches look routine. He’s also a much better athlete than given credit for, and even has a bit of wiggle in the open field. Kincaid fits perfectly within this offense next to Dawson Knox. Don’t be shocked if he becomes a primary target of Josh Allen sooner than later.
Image Source: Brian Rothmuller/Getty Images
26. Dallas Cowboys: DL Mazi Smith
Grade: B
This may have been a bit of a reach. Smith mostly was seeing high second-round projections. However, his selection does fit a need for Dallas. The nose guard spot was a bit of an issue last year. Smith should be an upgrade over Johnathan Hankins as a guy who can stop the run and take on double teams. Smith is your classic run stuffing defensive tackle with some ability to rush the passer. Also helping his cause is the pedigree he developed from playing under Jim Harbaugh.
Image Source: Getty Images
27. Jacksonville Jaguars: OT Anton Harrison
Grade: B-
This move was clearly made to protect Jacksonville’s most precious asset in Trevor Lawrence. He was a sound player for OU, often relying upon a vicious punch at the point of attack. With Harrison being a bit smaller than most starting NFL tackles, he benefits from having plus-athleticism — particularly when getting to the next level on blocks. It’ll be interesting if Harrison eventually moves inside to guard. Much of that will be determined by the availability and production of Jacksonville’s presumed starters at tackle (Walker Little, Cam Robinson).
Image Source: William Purnell/Icon Sportswire/Getty Images
28. Cincinnati Bengals: DE Myles Murphy
Grade: B
The Bengals nabbed one of the ACC’s most productive players over the last couple of years. Murphy can play outside as an edge rusher but also tuck inside in obvious passing situations. With a big wingspan and a quick get-off, there’s a lot to like about his game. Murphy also gets the benefit in going to a team where he can slowly break into the rotation rather than being expected to start right off the bat. This could help his development further. Also — with the AFC featuring a huge group of high-end quarterbacks — any team (in this case the Bengals) can’t have enough elite pass rushers.
Image Source: Nick Cammett/Getty Images
29. New Orleans Saints: DL Bryan Bresee
Grade: B+
Murphy’s college teammate was selected with the next pick in the draft. Coming out of high school, Bresee was presumed to be arguably the best prep prospect. While he was a bit inconsistent in college, the talent always flashed. You’re looking at a versatile defensive lineman who can play virtually any position across the front line. Bresee is very good against the run, and does have some pass-rushing capabilities as well. With the Saints in a bit of a rebuild, he should be able to come in right away and enjoy some decent playing time.
Image Source: John Byrum/Getty Images
30. Philadelphia Eagles: DE Nolan Smith
Grade: A
For some reason, Smith dropped in the draft all the way to the end of the 1st round. Some projections had the Eagles ironically selecting him at No. 10. After drafting Jalen Carter at that spot, the Eagles dipped back into the Georgia pond for another plus-athlete. Smith is 240 pounds with 4.39 speed in the 40. He made a name for himself coming off the edge as a situational pass rusher — though his collective athleticism enables him to play as a guy standing up in coverage. With the Eagles employing an attack-minded defense, Smith really does seem like an ideal fit.
Image Source: Brandon Sloter/Getty Images
31. Kansas City Chiefs: DE Felix Anudike-Uzomah
Grade: B
The Chiefs ended up taking a kid from right in their backyard. It’s not a surprise to see Kansas City go defense with this selection. When you’re in a conference with Joe Burrow, Josh Allen, Trevor Lawrence, Lamar Jackson, Justin Herbert and Aaron Rodgers, having ample pass-rushing talent is imperative. Anundike-Uzomah overwhelms opponents with first-step quickness off the edge. He’s got a terrific ability to disengage with tackles using a lethal pair of hands. Hailing from K-State, the fan base will love the energy with which Anundike-Uzomah plays with.
Image Source: Scott Winters/Getty Images
