2. Josh Allen — Buffalo Bills
Mark Konezny/USA TODAY Sports
2023 Stats: 5 games, completed 128-of-175 passes, 1407 yards, 11 TD, 5 INT, 120 rush yards, 3 rush TD
Josh Allen’s performance as a rookie was a mixed bag. Gifted with extreme arm-talent and dynamic legs, Allen has all the tools to succeed in the league. However, Allen struggled mightily throwing the football in Year 1. He has found success as a runner over his career, and Allen’s improved accuracy has now pushed him into the ‘elite’ conversation. There were flashes of Allen making strides in Year 2 — improved accuracy and better decision-making — and the last three years Allen was absolutely sensational. While Buffalo has failed to progress in the postseason, Allen has shown up in big games and looks to eventually get over the hump in 2023.