Andrew Firestone and Jen Schefft
Southern California native Andrew Firestone was picked to be the main man for the show’s third season. Ultimately, his path for love led him to a woman named Jen Schefft. She was so smitten by Firestone, she decided to not only accept his proposal — but also move to California to be with him. Ultimately, did the couple stay together?
In a word, no. They broke off their engagement later that year amicably. Firestone married another woman five years later (with whom he currently has three children). The Ohio native Schefft also married in 2009, and is said to have two children of her own.
Image Source: Robert Mora/Getty Images